Skip to content

UK set to sell sensitive NHS records to commercial companies with no meaningful privacy protections


How to OPT OUT – You must do this in FEBRUARY (ie 3 weeks left).  NO2ID OPT OUT FORM.

The UK government’s Health and Social Care Information Centre quietly announced plans to share all patient records held by the National Health Service with private companies, from insurers to pharmaceutical companies.

The information sharing is on an opt-out basis, so if you don’t want your “clinical records, mental health consultations, drug addiction rehabilitation details, dsexual health clinic attendance and abortion procedures” shared, along with your “GP records, HS numbers, post-codes, gender, date of birth,” you need to contact your doctor and opt out of the process.

This is a complex issue. Large data-sets are the lifeblood of epidemiology and evidence-based care and policy, and the desire to extract useful health information from this data is a legitimate one.

However, it’s clear that no one involved in the process gives a damn about privacy. These data-sets — which will be sold on the open market to commercial operators — are “anonymized” and “pseudonymized” through processes that don’t work, have never worked, and are well-documented to be without any basis in reality.

And that’s the thing that brings the whole enterprise out of the realm of legitimate scientific project and into the realm of corporatist hucksterism. Once the architects of this project announced that its privacy protections would be based on junk science, they lost any claim they had to operating in good faith.

Effectively, the managers of this programme have said, “We can’t figure out how to protect the most private, potentially damaging facts of your life, so we’re not going to try.”

It is pure cynicism, and it makes me furious. It brings the whole field of evidence-based medicine into disrepute. It is a scandal. And as it goes ahead, it will spectacularly destroy the lives of random people in the UK through the involuntary, totally foreseeable disclosure of health information, in ways that make the general public leery of any participation in this kind of inquiry.

If you set about to discredit the open data movement, you could do no better than this.

Update: As if that wasn’t bad enough, Noemi adds, “The contract for handling and managing the care data has been given to ATOS. This is the same company whose disability benefit assessment has been found to be flawed and unacceptable in 40% of cases by the Audit Commission.” Here’s more.

How to OPT OUT – You must do this in FEBRUARY (ie 3 weeks left).


Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: