Skip to content

Japanese court orders Google to remove harmful search results – RT


The Tokyo District Court ordered Google Thursday to remove over 100 search results that had invaded a man’s privacy by alluding to crimes he may have been involved in and other criminal activity, in a similar verdict to Europe’s right to be forgotten.

Judge Nobuyuki Seki said in a document obtained by the Kyodo News Agency, a non-profit Japanese news agency, that some of the search results did “infringe” the man’s “personal rights” and that “Google, which manages the search engine, has the obligation to delete them.”

The man requested an injunction in June saying that information being trawled up in search results was related to events which took place more than ten years ago and that his life had been threatened as a result of the reports of his alleged inappropriate behavior.

Judge Seki said the man had suffered “actual harm” and an infringement of “personal rights” and ordered the web giant to remove about 120 of the 230 search results.

Although the judge did admit that Google “plays an important role so that the internet can be used effectively.”

The man’s lawyer, Tomohiro Kanda, said he thought this was the first time such a court ruling has been made in Japan.

Tomohiro said the case came under Japanese privacy and defamation law, but the ruling also considered the “right to be forgotten” ruling in Europe in May in which the Court of Justice of the European Union ordered Google to remove the personal data of a Spanish man so that it didn’t appear in web searches anymore.

Take Home Message

– The Right to be Forgotten (now called the Right to Erasure) is critical to the safety of the data subject

– Results that are kept “forever” are disproportionate and harmful to a data subject.

– In real life, if you go bankrupt, you are allowed a current account and credit card after so many years.. with the “forever” nonsense from Google, you’d never be given a second chance.  We all need to wipe the slate clean at some point… and the Right to be Forgotten allows you to move on from losing a job, bankruptcy, or some other traumatic event.  The person or “Data Subject” must come before the profits of Google.

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: